The concept of strategic culture has become widely used in the field of international relations, primarily in the context of efforts to explain the distinctive strategic behaviors of states through reference to their unique strategic properties. The report focuses on three relevant issues regarding. Strategic theory, as has been emphasized, is routinely about the study of how valuesystems inform and influence ends and means, and if that is what people mean by the study of culture then strategic theory is, ipso facto, concerned with the study of cultural variables. Thinking about strategic culture goetheuniversitat. Culture theory, an interrelated school of anthropological and semiotic thought challenges the view that culture is the entity of a single community serrat, 2008. The first question posed in the introductory section of this work concerns whether or not a nonstate actor can have a strategic culture. Bridging theory and practice eric flamholtz and yvonne randle frontmatter more information. Essential to employ darwinstheory of evolution with upgrades. Lantis strategic insights is a monthly electronic journal produced by the center for contemporary conflict at the naval postgraduate school in monterey, california. This paper explores the extent to which this is useful by means of an analysis of the theoretical debate juxtaposed to practical case studies. The secret of longterm success is the ability to adapt to change.
Specifically, this article is a direct reply to recent criticisms of so. The concept of strategic culture refers to a nations traditions, values, attitudes, patterns of behaviour, habits, symbols, achievements and particular ways of adapting to the environment and solving problems with respect to the threat or use of force. This paper charts the evolution of the theory of strategic culture through several. Strategic theory is the branch of social theory concerned with the use of force to achieve the goals of one community in conflict with others.
This essay charts the evolution of the theory of strategic culture through several gen erations of scholarly work inside, and outside, the discipline. The second was a conference to develop an academic syllabus for a course that would introduce the concept of strategic culture to senior undergraduate students studying international relations and security studies. Foreign policy nuclear weapon security policy political culture strategic choice. It explicitly links the field of industrial relations to the field of strategic management theory emphasizing coevolution, blending porterlike outsidein approaches with resource based insideout approaches into. Strategic culture foundation provides a platform for exclusive analysis, research and policy comment on eurasian and global affairs. Mar 01, 2011 the theory of manageable chaos put into practice sergei shashkov independent analyst and researcher an act of selfimmolation by a tunisian street vendor in protest of the confiscation of his wares by municipal officials in december was covered in the media as the catalyst for mass riots in tunisia, which later spread to egypt, yemen.
Specifically, this article is a direct reply to recent criticisms of socalled firstgeneration theorists of strategic culture. A synthesis of theory and research on principal leadership, school culture, and school effectiveness beverly adams lancaster parker abstract the national push for increased accountability, the demand for academic achievement for all students, as defined by highstakes testing, and sanctions imposed on. Introduction the concept of strategic culture has become increasingly important in the 21st century. China, strategic culture, 21st century, indian ocean, string of pearls, maritime security, belt and road initiative.
Pdf on jul 30, 2018, kerry longhurst and others published on strategic culture. The effect of strategic choices and management control. Perhaps the most noteworthy major study on strategic culture to. Reviewing recent literature strategic insights, volume iv, issue 10 october 2005, available at. From clausewitz to constructivism strategic insights, volume iv, issue 10 october 2005 by jeffrey s.
A synthesis of theory and research on principal leadership. Strategic culturehow it affects strategic outputs csc 1998 subject area strategic issues executive summary title. Culture theorys holistic perspective, englobing the needs common to all people, does not lend itself to easy action. Prime time for strategic culture, unpublished paper 2006 darryl howlett, strategic culture. As such, it is in the public domain, and under the provisions of title 17, united states code, section 105, it may not be.
It argues that the notion of strategic culture can be useful in assessing the context in which the. Introduction to strategic leadership 3 in strategic leadership, we will help you develop that bigpicture understanding of how to guide your actions. International security studies and strategic culture the question of culture did not attract much attention in international security studies and international relations theory until the last ten to fifteen years, when interest in culture, strategic culture, and other ideational explanations for the behavior of states has grown. Strategic culture offers an alternative to unitary rational actor conceptions of strategic decisionmaking. Abstract wars inherent uncertainty makes subjective judgment an inseparable part of strategic choice. Strategic change can then lead to other organizational changes relating to technology, structure and culture of the company. Despite this, a great deal of confusion remains regarding what strategic culture is. Reactive communication successful communication does not just happen it is a result of sound research, meticulous planning, careful implementation and evaluation.
View strategic culture research papers on academia. Feb 14, 2011 this essay will posit that the eu does have a strategic culture, but one still in infancy, beset by weaknesses and potentially insurmountable obstacles. The theory of manageable chaos put into practice sergei shashkov independent analyst and researcher an act of selfimmolation by a tunisian street vendor in protest of the confiscation of his wares by municipal officials in december was covered in the media as the catalyst for mass riots in tunisia, which later spread to egypt, yemen. On strategic culture the decision making process in matters of defence is not an abstract con struct based purely in the present moment but is, rather, steeped in the. This strategic culture analysis is not just a realm for the strategic planner. The sources of a particular communitys strategic culture.
For example, to support a new strategy, the management team of a company. Nevertheless, critics charged that there was little progress toward the development of a unified theory of culture that might rival neorealism, and at the end of. In his defence, gray has modified the theory so that strategic culture represents a context for framing strategic decision making, not the causality of strategic behaviour. In leading strategic change, eric flamholtz and yvonne randle demonstrate that the key to longterm organizational success is the ability to adapt to and manage different types of change. Strategic management of communication the old flying by the seat of the pants approach to solving public relations problems is over. Specifically, this article is a direct reply to recent criticisms of socalled firstgeneration. Yitzhak klein, a theory of strategic culture, comparative strategy, vol. To demonstrate this, we shall explore key diplomatic efforts to enhance european strategic integration, responses to world events and operational deployments, how these have progressively shaped a common strategic culture, and how numerous.
May 21, 2010 2 see, for example, paul cornish and geoffrey edwards, beyond the eunato dichotomy. The theory of strategic culture identifies the factors that influence. It is worth noting that there is an explicit purpose to discussing strategic culture before covering grand strategy. Strategic cultures, the set of beliefs held by strategic decisionmakers regarding the political object of war and the most effective means of achieving it, arise out of strategy. The concept of organizational culture organizational culture is one of the major issues in academic research and education, in organization theory as well as in management practice. The strategic culture of a countrys strategic community will affect that communitys strategic outputs defense policy, strategy, etc. Strategic culture, a theory which has garnered attention of late, is not strictly speaking, a new idea. Johnston defines strategic culture as ranked grand strategic preferences derived from central paradigmatic assumptions about the nature of conflict and the enemy, and collectively shared by. It can contribute to understanding and promoting development.
String of pearls and chinas emerging strategic culture. Prime time for strategic culture notwithstanding the criticisms that have been offered, and will be offered in more detail below, of scholars who overindulge in the heady delights of theory. It aims at a systematic understanding of how to employ armed forces to advance political, social, economic, cultural, or ideological interests. Jofre foreword the present report is the result of an ongoing study on the patterns and trends on both the theory and practice in the field of strategic management.
The most telling criticism of political culture theory is that it has coped very. In this way, strategic culture can provide a causal non tautological understanding32 of strategic decision making. As long as one recognizes that in strategic culture one is discerning tendencies, not rigid determinants, then the end result should be richer theory and more effective practice. The effect of strategic choices and management control systems on organizational performance 336 r. Turn strategic cultural analysis on self and society. Culture theory strengthens the expectation that markets work, not because they are comprised of autonomous individuals who are free of social sanctions but because they are powered by social beings and their distinctive ideas, beliefs, values, and knowledge. The term strategic culture was coined by jack snyder while analysing the nuclear warfare of the former soviet. Lantis abstract this paper charts the evolution of the theory of strategic culture through several generations of scholarship and explores contemporary arguments about the role of culture in shaping national security policy. Dec 01, 2008 culture theory, an interrelated school of anthropological and semiotic thought challenges the view that culture is the entity of a single community serrat, 2008. From clausewitz to contructivism, unpublished paper 2006 colin s. The theory and practice of strategy in business organizations s.
Around the same period, max manwaring called for the old nuclear theology relating to. This essay will posit that the eu does have a strategic culture, but one still in infancy, beset by weaknesses and potentially insurmountable obstacles. This paper charts the evolution of the theory of strategic culture through several generations of scholarship, both inside and outside the discipline, and explores contemporary arguments about the role of culture in shaping national security policy. The beginnings of a european strategic culture, international affairs, 77. Towards a common strategic culture within the european security and defence policy, iis working paper, no. Strategic culture strategic culture as an international relations theory posits that nations are fundamentally influenced by their culture and such influence carries over to strategic decisions and operations. The tale then proceeds to explore the reasons why culture matters greatly. Lastly, small states threat perceptions from the neighborhood over time dictate the formation of strategic culture provocative vs.
Constructivism, strategic culture, and the iraq war. The concept of strategic culture affirmed springerlink. Williams, broadening the agenda of security studies. We are covering political, economic, social and security issues worldwide. The resulting conception of strategic culture presents a less deterministic account of culture than that found in much existing literature regarding. Wars instrumental nature its logical and practical. Organizations develop success formulas or winning business. The theory of strategic culture consists of basic assumptions about the strategic environment, including threat perception, as well as assumptions about the options to respond to the threats. But, culture theory alone pays simultaneous and even attention to these needs and makes possible a focus on the whole and the parts, on contexts and contents, on values and value systems, and on strategic relation. Overall, we rate the strategic culture foundation scf a questionable source based on extreme right wing bias, promotion of russian propaganda and conspiracy theories as well as a complete lack of transparency with the goal to deceive readers. Second, the content of small state strategic culture focuses primarily on foreign and security policy issues that originate in their neighborhood. Strategic cultures can be compared and analyzed by means. Despite this, a great deal of confusion remains regarding what strategic culture is, and how it may be used in the. The first generation of theory strikes back takes the scholarly argument about the study, and meaning, of strategic culture to a new stage.
The discussion of the dimensions will be briefly discussed. Strategic culture of small states the case of asean. To demonstrate this, we shall explore key diplomatic efforts to enhance european strategic integration, responses to world events and operational deployments, how these have progressively shaped a common. Strategic culturehow it affects strategic outputs author. Strategic cultures, the set of beliefs held by strategic decisionma kers regarding the political object of war and the most effective means of achieving it, arise out of.
221 458 1173 1388 848 1534 1540 1478 659 679 98 879 490 30 153 1319 224 158 200 1286 869 1224 1350 1433 117 93 303 1007 990 829 1252 97 952